New York, North America, USA

NYC Eats: Food Tour with Free Tours by Foot

December 18, 2013

In the early 1800s, Washington Square Park used to be a mass burial ground. On the side of the park stood a 300-year-old hanging elm tree, whose sole function was precisely that – to hang convicts and criminals. They were then thrown into the burial ground nearby. Talk about a convenient location!


Fast forward 200 years to a sunny Saturday afternoon last week when Julia and I stood underneath the branches of said elm tree, listening to Meredith, our tour guide, regaling us in these historical facts. Today, the park is no longer a mass burial ground, but it has transformed itself to a popular hang-out spot in the heart of Greenwich Village, one of the most sought-after (therefore very expensive) neighborhoods in Manhattan. On that particular afternoon, a crowd formed in the middle of the park to witness some kind of a performance while a grand piano stood a few feet from the Arch begging to be played. That particular afternoon also happens to be our scheduled Greenwich Village Food Tour with Free Tours by Foot.

The aforementioned hanging elm tree

The aforementioned hanging elm tree

In a place as big as New York City, it’s easy enough to consult Trip Advisor/Yelp/Urban Spoon/what-have-you for a list of popular restaurants, but the amount of information offered can be very overwhelming to sort through. I mean, a quick search on Yelp yields 34,517 results! This is where Free Tours by Foot come in! They’re focused on a certain part of the city (like Greenwich Village or Lower East Side) and are usually led by a local who has gone through most, if not all, the restaurants in the area and hence can make sound recommendations on who has the best what. Here is a recap of what Greenwich Village has to offer.

Mamoun’s Falafel

119 MacDougal St., New York, NY 10012
The menu in Mamoun's Falafel

The menu in Mamoun’s Falafel

At 3 for $1, these falafels serve to be a snack choice that is both delicious and budget-friendly. Have them as soon as they are out of the frying oils and don’t forget to dip them in the mixture of tahini and the hot sauce! Just be careful with the hot sauce – we’ve been told it’s deadly! You’ve been warned.


Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

111 MacDougal St., New York, NY 10012



Located a quick walk down the street from Mamoun’s is the Artichoke Pizza. Its highly-famous bechamel sauce is made from a tightly-guarded recipe that is only known to the owners. Topped with cheese and artichoke and sold at $4.75 per slice, it is a delicious and (very) filling lunch meal! So filling, in fact, that our guide told us to only buy 1 slice and share it with a friend if we were to come back there for a meal.

Faicco’s Italian Specialties

260 Bleecker St., New York, NY 10014


From Artichoke, we crossed 6th Ave. to Bleecker St., in the West Village. Our first stop on this side of Avenue of the Americas (another name for 6th Ave., as written on the road sign) was Faicco’s Italian Specialties where we tried their arancinis, or cheese-filled, deep-fried rice balls, for $1 each. I wasn’t a big fan of these, but then again, I’m quite the anomaly in the food industry – I don’t like Nutella – so don’t take my opinion too seriously.


Bantam Bagels

283 Bleecker St., New York, NY 10014

Bantam Bagels offer a different way of eating New York bagels: instead of serving them piled with your choice of topping, the bagels here were filled with them. Plus, they are bite-sized, so you can try many different flavours at once, without feeling too full and too guilty afterwards. Both Julia and I opted out from trying them because we each had a massive bagel for breakfast that morning, so we were “bageled out”, as Julia would say, and didn’t feel like eating anything else remotely resembling a bagel. However, the oohs and aahs coming from the rest of group were enough to tell us they were delicious!


Bleecker Street Pizza

69 7th Ave. S, New York, NY 10014

Located on the busy corner of 7th Ave. and Bleecker St., this pizza joint can be easily missed were it not for the signs that screams “The Food Network named us ‘Best Pizza in NY'”.


True to this title, the thin-crust, Tuscan-style Nonna Maria Pizza we got was amazing! The tomato sauce was ridiculously delicious and the crispy, oven-roasted basil topping was to die for. This was our favourite stop for the food tour!


Sugar & Plumm

257 Bleecker St., New York, NY 10014


We ended the tour here at Sugar & Plumm, a chic chocolatier and dessert store displaying a colourful array of artisan macarons. The graham crackers, creme-brulee cookies, and raspbery macarons offered to us as samples were enough to fill our cravings for sweets. Save for a cup of latte, I didn’t buy anything here as things were priced way over my budget. The latte? That was well-priced and yummy!


This food tour was my favourite activity during our weekend in NYC. Not only did we learn of budget-friendly eats in the city, we also learned about the interesting history of the areas, something that is easily missed if we didn’t have a guide to tell us. Meredith was very friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable as she gave us one recommendation after another as to where to eat in the city. The fact that the tour is only focused on a specific area of the city also helps to break this massive city into bite-sized pieces that’s much less intimidating (which I loved!). Oh and did I mention they are pay-what-you-can tours? Incredible! So, next time you’re in NYC, be sure to check them out!

Have you been in a food tour? If so, where? Were you surprised that I didn’t like those arancinis? Me too! I mean, I’m Asian – we LIVE on rice. You’d think rice balls, deep-fried, AND filled with cheese would be an amazing recipe for culinary greatness, right? Nope. 


  • Reply Rob @ Hungry Escapades December 19, 2013 at 11:15 am

    Oh these look delicious and some real bargains too. I think I ate my body weight in pizza when I was in NYC! Yum!

    • Reply Pauline December 19, 2013 at 2:46 pm

      I know, right! It was, by far, the cheapest food tour I’ve gone on – I must have spent only $5.25 on food samples in total! Definitely food tour done right!

  • Reply Let's Talk Budget: How Much Does a Weekend in NYC Cost? | Tales of a Pilgrim February 8, 2014 at 1:51 pm

    […] With regards to food, we chose to go the simple route and still ate really well. No, we didn’t have extravagant meals at 5-star restaurants, but we did have an amazing Ethiopian food in the Village, and not to mention the delicious cream-cheese-loaded-bagel we had for breakfast that very same day. Manhattan can be terribly expensive, but it doesn’t have to be as long as you are street-smart and you know where to find what you are looking for. Know that you can NEVER go wrong if you eat where the locals eat. […]

  • Reply New York City Eats | Tales of a Pilgrim March 1, 2014 at 4:31 pm

    […] Gaby’s addresses and a couple of places and called it a day). Luckily for us, we went on a Greenwich Village Food Tour with Free Tours by Foot, where we learned about all the local establishments in the area; information that eventually came […]

  • Leave a Reply

    CommentLuv badge